Showing posts with label Denise Paul. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Denise Paul. Show all posts

Friday, December 6, 2013

#31 (7.8): The Rings of Akhaten.

A lullaby for a sleeping god.

1 episode. Approx. 45 minutes. Written by: Neil Cross. Directed by: Farren Blackburn. Produced by: Marcus Wilson, Denise Paul.


THE PLOT:

The Doctor takes Clara to the distant future, to a truly alien environment: The Rings of Akhaten. This is a system of small worlds, circling the giant planet Akhaten, from which the people of this system believe all life originated. The Doctor and Clara have arrived in time for the Festival of Offerings, a holy event that takes place only once every thousand years, when all the rings align. "It's quite a big thing," the Doctor explains, "like Pancake Tuesday."

Clara is distracted when she sees a little girl running away in apparent fear. She goes after the child and finds her hiding. She learns the child is Merry Galel (Emilia Jones), selected at birth to be "The Queen of Years." Merry is afraid because she has been chosen to sing a special song to their "Old God," also known as "grandfather," and is terrified that she will get it wrong. Clara reassures her, and even goes with the Doctor to watch her perform.

Merry sings beautifully... but a tendril of energy emerges from the pyramid and snatches her away. The Doctor and Clara chase after the girl - but soon, all three of them are trapped inside the pyramid. The parasitic "Old God" is about to awaken, determined to feast on Merry... on the Doctor and Clara... and on the seven worlds in their entirety!


CHARACTERS:

The Doctor: The teaser sees him following the leaf from "Page One" of Clara's book, 101 Places to See. He traces it back to the first meeting of Clara's parents, then spies on her as a child and even watches her mother's funeral from afar. It's obsessive behavior, and disturbing to watch - all the moreso with the show ending as the Doctor's smile turns into a very dark scowl the second Clara's no longer watching.

He's much more himself when actually traveling with Clara, particularly once the crisis strikes. Matt Smith gets two of the very best monologues he's had. The first comes when talking to Merry, pushing her to realize her worth as an individual by describing her uniqueness as elements of an exploding star, combined and ripped apart over and over again until they finally came together in just the right way to form her. It's a great speech... And even so it is dwarfed at the episode's climax, when he faces down the "Old God" by daring it to consume his own memories: all that he's seen, all that he's lost, all that he's known.

Clara: Much more a full individual in this episode. Her nurturing side is on full display in her scenes with young Merry. As soon as she sees the young girl running off, she can't help but follow to try to help. She is very Doctorish herself as she talks Merry into singing by telling her that she won't get it wrong. When Merry is snatched, Clara is ready to fight the Doctor into going after her and is ready to give up something personally precious. When the Doctor hints at her similarity to her other selves, she insists on being seen as a unique individual - but I find myself wondering if her words at the end about futures "that never got lived" and days "that never were" might hold a clue to her full nature.


THOUGHTS:

I am impressed.

I wasn't expecting much out of The Rings of Akhaten. In general, new Who follows a consistent trend: A big opener, followed by one or two throwaways. That was what I thought this was going to be.

I certainly did not expect what I got, though I have no idea how I could have. This is one of the most unusual stories since the series' return. The first half recalls the style of Christopher H. Bidmead's Who, only with an emotional core added to the high concepts. The story is often bizarre, visually remarkable for something made on a television budget, and surprisingly heartfelt.

It works as much on a figurative level as on the literal one. Sure, the little girl in peril and the monster who claims to be a god work on their own terms. But the real interest is in seeing this tied to Clara and particularly to the Doctor.

The Doctor is a grandfather, as he reminds us when he and Clara arrive. The "Old God" is also referred to as "grandfather." When the Doctor confronts the "grandfather," he snaps that it is not a god but "a parasite, eaten out with jealousy and envy and longing for the lives of others." He could almost be describing the way he viewed himself at his lowest point in Series Six, when he looked back on his companions and could only see lives that he had ruined. The "grandfather" is prophesied to wake, wreak destruction, and then "embark upon a new odyssey among the stars" - which is basically the Doctor's entire existence, from a certain point of view. It's also worth observing that the Doctor's extraordinary defiance fails to stop the grandfather. It's a completely different offering that chases it away, not the Doctor's.

All of this is punctuated by some of the most fantastic visual moments since the series' return. There are epic visuals: the Doctor and Clara, standing before a gorgeous CGI shot of the titular rings, with the small worlds and the pyramid all floating in space before the brightness of Akhaten itself; the ceremony, with Merry singing to the pyramid as it floats across from her and as a large, multi-species audience looks on; the Doctor, standing before the angry brightness of the "Old God," defying it with himself.

Just as important, though, are the smaller beats: The opening shot, of the leaves rustling before the wind acts on just the right leaf at just the right time; Clara, sitting on her stairs waiting for the Doctor to keep their date from the last episode, a smile very gradually crossing her face as she hears him arrive and realize that he's arrived on time (a notable difference from his inability to be on time for Amy); Clara, giving Merry an encouraging smile like a mother at a school recital just before the little girl sings. Each visual seems precisely framed, individual panels forming a larger whole.

The Rings of Akhaten may be the most utterly individual episode of since The Doctor's Wife. It met with a mixed reception; but for me, this one wins full marks, and I've only liked it more on rewatching.


Overall Rating: 10/10.

Previous Story: The Bells of Saint John
Next Story: Cold War

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Thursday, December 5, 2013

#30 (7.7): The Bells of Saint John.

The Doctor protects Clara from the evils of the Internet.
(No, not porn)

1 episode. Approx. 47 minutes. Written by: Steven Moffat. Directed by: Colm McCarthy. Produced by: Marcus Wilson, Denise Paul.


THE PLOT:

The Doctor has taken refuge in a 13th century monastery to contemplate the mystery of Oswin/Clara. He has been there some time, when the monks report that the impossible has happened: The bells of Saint John are ringing. "Saint John" is a marking on the exterior of the TARDIS, and its "bells" are the telephone - a phone which should not ring.

The Doctor answers, only to find himself on the line with a present-day version of Clara (Jenna-Louise Coleman). This Clara is trying to access the Internet.  An unidentified woman in a shop gave her the Doctor's number as a computer help line. Realizing that he is talking to the very woman he's been looking for, the Doctor hops into the TARDIS and travels literally to her doorstep - just in time to find her in mortal peril!

A sinister company is using a rogue WiFi network to hack not into other computers, but into human beings. The victims are uploaded into the WiFi to support their mysterious "client." The Doctor arrives in time to save Clara, then works on tracking these villains back to their lair - a corporate headquarters located in The Shard. But this company and its office manager, the ruthless Miss Kizlet (Celia Imrie), are only puppets. The Doctor has captured the attention of an old enemy, and he has yet to even realize it!


CHARACTERS:

The Doctor: When he does find this latest Clara, he comes off as a complete basket case, pushing himself in front of her and even expecting her to remember him - despite her being a different individual than Oswin and the other Clara. After he rescues her, she finally comes down to talk with him, allowing him to get to know her just a little bit. He marvels at how she's the same as the other two versions of her, but also appreciates her loyalty to the family she's caring for. When she's threatened again, he frees her in an ingenious fashion, using a classic magician's trick of misdirection.

Clara: The third incarnation of Clara Oswin Oswalt is presumably the one the series will be sticking with. Like the other variants we've seen, she is flirty, sharp-witted, and fast-talking... basically, the Steven Moffat dreamgirl. The role remains a cypher, though that's obviously part of the point. As flashes to her other appearances remind us, these three characters are all the same role - something which I'm guessing will be explained down the line. Jenna-Louise Coleman continues to invest a tremendous amount of energy, and as a fan of Amy and Rory I'm genuinely astonished at how little I miss them.


THOUGHTS:

The Doctor taking refuge in a 13th century monastery is something that really only occurs so that Matt Smith can get an entrance and so that we can get the admittely fun incongruity of medieval monks involved in a telephone conversation. It's pointless from a plot standpoint - the same purpose could have been served by having the Doctor pick up a phone in the TARDIS - and makes no sense in context of the Doctor trying to solve the Oswin/Clara mystery. It's purely for effect.

I'm leading with that because, aside from yet another strained "Doctor Who?" gag (Moffat is much too fond of those), I don't have many criticisms of this story. The story is fast-paced and clever, with a light touch that belies how effectively it weaves continuity points together while simultaneously establishing the season villain.

The story grips right from the start, the teaser setting up the idea of people being snatched by filtering it through what appears to be a YouTube video warning others of the phenomenon. The warning is intercut with shots of people clicking on the Evil WiFi, then with shots of the aftermath. It ends with a visual flourish, a wonderfully-staged reveal that sets just the right tone going into credits.

Moffat and director Colm McCarthy manage a series of effective set pieces. There's an early scene in which the Doctor has a hacking duel with one of the villains. The screen fills up with text, mirroring a technique used in Moffat's own Sherlock. The moving text and the way the scene is edited and shot builds tremendous energy. A slower beat, as the Doctor and Clara have their first real conversation, is shot with him outside the house, below, as she talks to him from an upstairs window - reminiscent of the classic staging of the Romeo & Juliet balcony scene. This being modern Who, the bit of course shifts rapidly into another comedy/action scene involving a crashing airplane.

The set pieces keep coming, one after another, which keeps the momentum high throughout. The action/comedy tone also encourages the viewer to let down their guard... Which makes a final beat involving the most visible villain, Miss Kizlet, all the more effective. Her final lines take this despicable character and transform her into something completely different - and this is done in a way entirely consistent with the story's own rules. It's a genuinely chilling moment.

The entire package is given an extra layer of fun thanks to the chemistry of Matt Smith and Jenna-Louise Coleman. They are terrific individually, and even better together on-screen. If this episode is an indicator of what's to come, I think I'm going to thoroughly enjoy their partnership.


Overall Rating: 8/10.

Previous Story: The Snowmen
Next Story: The Rings of Akhaten

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Monday, January 7, 2013

#21 (6.12): Closing Time.

The Doctor is reunited with an old friend.

1 episode. Approx. 45 minutes. Written by: Gareth Roberts. Directed by: Steve Hughes. Produced by: Denise Paul.


THE PLOT

The Doctor is now traveling on his own, and he is keenly aware of his death at a fixed point at Lake Silencio. At what may be his lowest emotional point, he decides to pay a farewell visit to Craig (James Corden), his one-time flatmate. He is surprised to find Craig at a new home, taking care of the baby he had with Sophie (Daisy Haggard) while she is away.

The Doctor intends a short visit. But when he discovers evidence of alien technology, he investigates, taking a job at a shop when he discovers disappearances in the store's vicinity. It isn't long before he traces all this to its source: A damaged spaceship belonging to the Doctor's old enemies, the Cybermen!


CHARACTERS

The Doctor: I think I've finally figured it out. The Doctor falling "so much further" than he ever has before wasn't  the moment in A Good Man Goes to War at which his triumph and Amy's baby were snatched away. It's been his gradual loss of faith in himself since then: having to acknowledge that River's path is set in Let's Kill Hitler, sentencing Old Amy to oblivion, dashing Amy's faith so that she sees him as just "a madman in a box." Bit by bit, he has spent the last half of this season deciding that he is nothing but harmful to those around him. Hopefully, the events of this episode remind him that the mad man in a box truly can be a hero, giving him the faith in himself to (presumably) subvert his fate in the finale.

Craig: Reminds the Doctor of something he's forgotten: That he isn't really the cause of the deaths around him. Craig remembers their last encounter, and tells the Doctor that the people who died last time were "people you didn't know." He states that the place where he and his son are safest in a dangerous situation is with the Doctor. After all, for Craig and Sophie, the Doctor was their salvation.

Amy/Rory: Only glimpsed in passing this episode, walking through the store just as the Doctor's talking about coincidence. We see that they have moved on with their lives and appear happy, with Amy having achieved a certain level of fame modeling cosmetics. The Doctor is pleased to see her happy and successful - though I'll wager that will be interrupted in the next episode.

Cybermen: Purely a plot device, the Cybermen here are just a last foe for the Doctor to defeat on his last adventure. They ultimately aren't defeated by the Doctor, but instead by soppy sentiment, in what may well be the most unconvincing and mawkish climax of the entire series. Still, this episode isn't really about them, so their overeasy defeat actually doesn't destroy the show the way it would have done to a "normal" Cyberman story.


THOUGHTS

Series Five's The Lodger came just before the season ending fireworks. It was a small but pleasant episode. Before telling something on a larger scale than ever before, the show took a breath and reminded us of the human scale. The result was a success, making it little surprise that, one year later, the series tries to do the same thing over again.

When it sticks to being a human-scale comedy/drama, Closing Time works pretty well. Not as well as The Lodger did, mind you. The idea isn't as fresh, Daisy Haggard's largely-absent Sophie is missed, and the jokes just aren't as funny the second time around. Still, enough of the humor works to keep it turning over quite nicely for most of its running time, and Matt Smith and James Corden make an engaging duo. It particularly suits this Doctor to be forced into the mundane.

There's only one big problem: The Cyberman.

I don't think the Cybermen have ever been worse-used than they are here. It's not that the versions we see are weakened - Some of the best Cyber stories involve Cybermen in a weakened state. It's not even that their presence keeps interrupting the more interesting character material, such as the Doctor's "enhancement" of the baby's outer space diorama. The balance between the character story and the monster story may be off, but not so badly as to destroy a solid episode.

Unfortunately, the Cyber material goes from weak to atrocious at the end. In a season that's been marred by an unfortunate tendency toward heavy-handed sentiment, this ending turns out to be the biggest offender. Not only are the enemies defeated in a way that completely defuses them as a threat - The ending actually takes the most frightening aspect of the Cybermen and drowns it in such a way that I'd wonder how there could even be successful cyber-conversions. Forget shooting them with a slingshot - Turns out the Beatles were right and "all you need is love."

The solidity of the Doctor/Craig material manages to (just barely) keep this afloat. But I can't quite forgive the weakness of the Cybermen plot and particularly its resolution, meaning that I left this episode with a bad taste in my mouth.


Rating: 5/10.

Previous Story: The God Complex
Next Story: The Wedding of River Song

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads: